This review was originally written in 2007. It was moved from my general blog to my book review blog.
I enjoyed this book, but it is one of those books that I wish I had
gotten from the library, rather than buying myself. The story is just a
bit too far-fetched for me to feel comfortable with. But perhaps that
isn't quite accurate. There are some really far fetched books that I
completely enjoy. It is just that the characters in this book didn't
seem completely real to me. Each one was a bit too much like themselves
- too unidimensional, perhaps, is a better way to put it. Even though
the characters weren't exactly stereotypes, their behaviors were fairly
predictable. Perhaps that is OK, though, because it simplifies a rather
convoluted story.
Nevertheless, for kids who enjoy
mysteries and puzzling out what is happening as the story unfolds, this
is a rewarding read. Some of the puzzles are easy, some much harder.
This might make for a good read aloud. But, I still can't figure out
Mr. Benedict's first name. Sigh.
No comments:
Post a Comment